Who Owns a Country’s Integrity Story? By Niedja Santos
Who speaks for a country's integrity?
Foreign ministries have an obvious role in articulating international commitments, but they are far from the only actors shaping its credibility. But consider the public auditor whose findings reveal the gap between rules and practice, the procurement official whose decisions put institutional integrity to the test, or the judge whose rulings attract international scrutiny. Investigative journalists may uncover connections that official narratives leave unexplored. Citizens, businesses and diasporic communities also shape how a country is perceived abroad through their encounters with its institutions. International partners carry national commitments into wider networks, while foreign audiences interpret, question and sometimes challenge their credibility.
What if some of the most consequential actors in a country's integrity story are precisely those who neither speak on behalf of the state nor consider themselves participants in public diplomacy?
The question exposes a fundamental tension in anticorruption public diplomacy. Governments can develop strategies, formulate messages and promote an image of national integrity. What they cannot do is determine entirely how those messages will be understood or whether they will be believed. Claims about integrity are especially vulnerable to scrutiny because they invite comparison with what institutions actually do. And many of those institutions operate far beyond the reach of diplomatic communication. Foreign ministries, law enforcement agencies, regulators, development institutions and civil society bring different forms of authority, expertise and evidence into this process. International partners and foreign audiences, in turn, have their own experiences in interpreting, validating or contesting those claims. A country's integrity story is shaped through these encounters, often in ways that governments neither anticipate nor control.
The resulting challenge is not simply one of coordinating multiple voices. It concerns the relationship between what a country communicates, what its institutions do and how both are interpreted through international engagement. This distinction becomes particularly important when integrity is understood not merely as a policy commitment to be communicated, but as a dimension of national credibility shaped through international socialization. A country's anticorruption narrative does not acquire significance solely because it is articulated internationally. Its meaning develops through the interaction of strategic objectives, institutional capacities, resources, practices and the responses of those with whom the country engages.
The comparative analysis developed in Anticorruption Public Diplomacy: A Comparative Perspective on Denmark, New Zealand, the United States and South Korea shows how differently this relationship can unfold. In Denmark, development assistance, technical cooperation and economic diplomacy translate a reputation for integrity into international influence. Yet the Danske Bank scandal illustrates how corporate misconduct can complicate the very moral authority on which that projection depends. New Zealand offers a different configuration: its international credibility rests less on explicit declarations of virtue than on institutional oversight, cooperation with civil society and the extension of good-governance principles through Pacific development partnerships. In the United States, anticorruption diplomacy is closely connected to the extraterritorial reach of domestic legislation, particularly the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, and to the country's influence in shaping multilateral standards. Enforcement is therefore more than a domestic legal matter; it also contributes to American influence internationally. Changes in enforcement priorities, however, inevitably raise questions about the consistency of that normative leadership. South Korea, presents yet another experience. Anticorruption reform has been closely associated with efforts to reshape the country's international identity. The commitment to eradicating deep-rooted evils has found expression in institutional reforms and engagement through APEC, the OECD and the Open Government Partnership. At the same time, persistent political–business entanglements continue to complicate the reformist image the country seeks to project.
Despite these differences, the four cases share an underlying grammar of anticorruption public diplomacy. Identities and interests, objectives, agents, activities, material and immaterial resources, and ideational factors associated with different styles of power are present across the cases. What differs is how countries bring these elements together, the weight they give to each and the institutional and international relationships through which they operate. The existence of this common grammar does not imply that countries follow the same path. Rather, it helps explain why integrity can become a source of legitimacy and international influence in different ways, and why that influence remains open to interpretation and contestation.
For those working in public diplomacy, there are practical implications here. Interagency coordination is clearly necessary, but the issue runs deeper. Much of what makes a country's international commitments credible happens in institutions over which foreign ministries and communications professionals have little direct influence.
Take corporate transparency. A foreign ministry may announce its government's commitment to strengthening it, but the real test often lies with company registries and their ability to maintain reliable information about beneficial ownership. The protection of whistleblowers offers another example. International commitments matter, but so does what happens when someone actually reports wrongdoing. Are disclosures handled appropriately? Is retaliation addressed? Similarly, cooperation against illicit financial flows depends on prosecutors, financial intelligence units and judicial authorities being able to exchange information and provide effective legal assistance. These may seem far removed from the daily concerns of public diplomacy. Yet their consequences can travel well beyond national borders. None of these activities needs to have a diplomatic purpose to influence how a country's commitment to integrity is understood abroad.
This is why engagement between foreign ministries and the institutions responsible for anticorruption policies deserves more attention. Such engagement should not be limited to collecting achievements, figures or examples that can be used in speeches and international campaigns. It should also help diplomats understand what is happening in practice, where difficulties remain and how national commitments can be explained without presenting an overly simplified picture.
The same applies to relationships beyond government. Civil society organizations, research networks and international organizations should not be seen merely as useful channels for disseminating messages. They bring their own knowledge, experiences and interpretations to the discussion. They may reinforce a country's claims, but they may also question them or draw attention to issues that official communication has overlooked.
And then there are foreign audiences. Their role is not limited to receiving messages and responding to them. They interpret a country's actions through their own experiences and expectations. Their criticism may reveal discrepancies between the image a government wishes to project and the way its conduct is understood abroad. Listening, in this sense, is not simply a communication technique. It is part of understanding how national commitments acquire meaning through international interaction.
This also raises a question about how public diplomacy success is assessed. A widely circulated statement, a successful campaign or a prominent international appearance may attract attention. But attention tells us little about whether a country's commitments are considered credible. That requires looking beyond visibility. Are public claims consistent with institutional conduct? What kinds of relationships are being built through international engagement? How do the people and organizations involved interpret those commitments? Where do they see consistency, and where do they identify contradictions? These are more difficult questions to answer than counting media mentions or measuring the reach of a campaign. Yet they bring us closer to understanding what anticorruption public diplomacy can achieve, and where its limits lie.
Ultimately, the question is less about who should control a country's integrity story than about how public diplomacy operates when so much of that story is shaped beyond the control of any single institution. Governments articulate commitments, institutions put them into practice, partners carry them into international networks, and audiences interpret, question or contest their meaning. Public diplomacy has a role in connecting these different dimensions, not in pretending that one institution can speak for all of them. Its value lies in bringing diplomatic representation into closer contact with the institutional practices and international relationships through which credibility develops. A country can seek to shape its integrity story. It cannot be its sole author.